SUPERHERO 

 “More men than I have put men to death, but I am the last man in the world that would take a man's life. Two years ago - even if my own life was at stake - and I am confident, if I thought a man would shoot me - I would give him a chance of keeping his life, and would part with my own; but if I knew that through him innocent persons' lives were at stake, I certainly would have to shoot him if he forced me to do so; but I would want to know that he was really going to take my innocent life.”

 

OR

SUPERVILLAIN

“I give fair warning to all those who have reason to fear me, not to attempt to reside in Victoria. Neglect this and abide by the consequences which shall be worse than the rust in the wheat. I do not wish to give this order full force without timely warning but I am an widows son outlawed and my orders must be obeyed!"

ACTIVITY

 

Based on what you have learnt by exploring and completing the other pages of this website, you are to decide individually if Ned Kelly should be regarded as a hero or as a villain.

 

Prepare a short argument (100 words approximately) that supports your view.

 

Prepare a few rebuttal points (approximately 3) that could be used to argue against the opposing team.

 

Make sure you include quotes and information that you discovered while exploring the website in your arguments and your rebuttal.

 

After doing so your teacher will inform you of the debate's structure that you will be participating in.

 

Poll

Is Ned Kelly a Hero or a Villain?

Hero (49)
78%

Villain (14)
22%

Total votes: 63

 

“I have outlived that care that curries public favour or dreads the public frown...let the hand of law strike me down if it will, but I ask that my story be heard and considered” –Ned Kelly